RESEARCH / Focused target
Divisibility modulo three of the A373308 coefficients
RELEASED FOUNDATIONS / PROPOSED CONNECTION
Research connections
All source anchors (1)
- Hanna's Cubed Binary Product ConjectureReleased anchor
Problem
The question
OEIS A373308, Paul D. Hanna, Jun 20 2024, gives the following NAME and
COMMENT, quoted verbatim from Library/Arith/hanna2024a373308.md.
NAME:
Expansion of Product_{n>=0} (1 - x^(2^n))^3.
COMMENT:
Conjecture: a(3n+1) and a(3n+2) are divisible by 3 for n >= 0.
The entry's separate Thue-Morse congruence for a(3n) and zero-index characterisation conjectures are context only; neither is claimed here.
Motivation
Our foothold
This is a first-tier recent OEIS conjecture. The target is the divisibility assertion for every natural index, with KPI = open problems resolved.
Gap
Missing bridges
The supplied search-seat record reports no proof found: the OEIS entry and revision history were read on 2026-09-09, followed by identifier searches on arXiv, MathOverflow, and GitHub. This Stage-B seat had no network access and did not independently repeat those searches. No exhaustive literature search or first-publication priority is asserted.
Route
Proposed approach
The infinite product in the NAME, Π_{n≥0}(1 − x^{2^n})³, is represented by its
defining functional equation A = (1 - X)^3 * A.subst (X^2) with A(0) = 1.
Mathlib has no infinite products of formal power series; the equation is the
exact characterising property, obtained by removing the first factor and
shifting the remaining factors. This is the honesty boundary: Lean proves
existence and uniqueness for that equation, not an identity involving a formal
infinite-product operator.
The integer sequence a is defined recursively with a(0) = 1 (multiplier 1).
For positive n its recurrence is
a(n) = Σ_{i=0}^{min(3,n)} C(3,i)(-1)^i [n-i even] a((n-i)/2).
The implementation sums through n using the coefficients of (1 - X)^3;
those beyond degree three vanish. Index subtraction and division are natural
number operations. generatingSeries = PowerSeries.mk a is the integer
formal power series A. generating_equation proves both A(0) = 1 and
A = (1 - X)^3 * A.subst (X^2). generating_unique uses strong induction
on coefficients to show that every B with constant coefficient 1 satisfying
that equation equals A.
Over ZMod 3, Frobenius gives (1 - X)^3 = 1 - X^3, so the reduced series
satisfies Ā = (1 - X^3) * Ā.subst (X^2). mod_three_support, via the private
solution_support strong induction, proves (a n : ZMod 3) = 0 whenever
3 ∤ n: both contributing halved indices n/2 and (n-3)/2 remain outside the
multiples of three and are smaller than n. The second contribution occurs
only when n is at least three and n-3 is even; the first requires n even.
hanna_conjecture then states 3 ∣ a (3*n+1) ∧ 3 ∣ a (3*n+2) for every n.
The separate Thue-Morse and zero-index conjectures are not claimed. The module has Mathlib-only imports, no D5 import, and generality G.
Falsifier
What would falsify this route
A natural index n for which either a(3*n+1) or a(3*n+2) is not divisible
by three would contradict the assertion. The orchestrator's exact check is
supporting evidence only; a finite check does not establish this universal
statement and was not rerun by this seat.
Evidence
Evidence to collect
- Lean module:
D5/S1/Recurrence/Invariants/CubedBinaryProductModThree.lean. - Main public theorem:
hanna_conjecture. - Companions:
generating_equation,generating_unique,mod_three_support. - Axioms: std3 (
propext,Classical.choice,Quot.sound), as reported for each public theorem by the implementation seat's#print axiomschecks. - The orchestrator reported verification of
make lean,make lean-report, andmake emitbefore this Stage-B edit; these were not rerun by this seat.
Triage
Scope assessment
theorem. The formal proof closes the quoted universal divisibility assertion
for the unique normalized functional-equation solution representing the NAME.
ASSUMED-UNVERIFIED
Unverified assumptions
The quotations, attribution, and date were supplied by the orchestrator and copied from the Library note. The OEIS revision history was read by the search seat on 2026-09-09, not by this network-disabled Stage-B seat. The reported literature scope was the OEIS entry and its revision history plus identifier searches on arXiv, MathOverflow, and GitHub; private MathSciNet and zbMATH indexes and the third-party Lean ecosystem were not exhaustively checked by this seat. First-publication priority and the external source's identification with the normalized functional equation are not kernel-checked facts.