RESEARCH / Focused target
First occurrences in the A335925 self-referential quotient recurrence
RELEASED FOUNDATIONS / PROPOSED CONNECTION
Research connections
All source anchors (1)
- First Occurrences in a Self-Referential Quotient RecurrenceReleased anchor
Problem
The question
OEIS A335925, NAME (%N, verbatim):
a(n) = a(floor((n-1)/a(n-1))) + 1 with a(1) = 1.
COMMENT (%C, verbatim; Altug Alkan, Jun 30 2020):
Least k such that a(k) = n are 1, 2, 5, 16, 65, 326, 1957, ... (Conjecture: This sequence is A000522).
Here A000522(0) = 1 and A000522(m) = m*A000522(m-1) + 1. The phrase "least k such that a(k) = m" is formalized as a hit at that index together with minimality among every positive index carrying m.
Motivation
Our foothold
This OEIS conjecture was recorded in 2020 and remained unchanged through the bounded source and literature checks recorded in preregistration issue #7464. The full unbounded hit-and-minimality statement resolves the conjecture rather than only extending its finite table.
Gap
Missing bridges
The search surfaces recorded in #7464 on 2026-09-13 returned the exact OEIS token only for A335925. Exact identifier searches reported OpenAlex 0, Crossref 0, DataCite 0, arXiv 0, MathOverflow 0, Math.SE 0, and GitHub code 0 apart from a directory mirror. The subsequent probe recorded the same zero-hit literature result. These are bounded searches, not exhaustive coverage or a priority claim.
Route
Proposed approach
Let T(0)=1 and T(r+1)=(r+1)*T(r)+1. The corrected block invariant is
a(T(r)) = r+1; for T(r) <= n < T(r+1), the value a(n) belongs to
{r,r+1}; and a(n)=r implies n < r*T(r). This corrected indexing was
re-preregistered in #7464 before Stage B. A two-step induction on r, with an
inner Nat.le_induction on n, establishes the block statement. Quotient-index
bounds use Nat.div_lt_iff_lt_mul. The value at the block start gives the hit,
and the block bound excludes every earlier positive occurrence.
Falsifier
What would falsify this route
One positive m whose least positive index k satisfying a(k)=m differs from
T(m-1) would contradict the theorem.
Evidence
Evidence to collect
- Lean module:
D5/S1/Recurrence/Invariants/SelfReferentialQuotientFirstOccurrence.lean. - Main theorem:
alkan_a335925. - Axioms: std3 (
propext,Classical.choice,Quot.sound). - The orchestrator evaluated the recurrence through n = 2*10^6. The first occurrences for m = 1 through 9 were 1, 2, 5, 16, 65, 326, 1957, 13700, and 109601.
- The search seat evaluated through n = 10^7 for m <= 11 with no mismatch, and compared the supplied b-file at 10000/10000 entries. These finite checks support but do not replace the universal proof.
Triage
Scope assessment
theorem. The formal result proves both existence at T(m-1) and minimality for
every positive m.
ASSUMED-UNVERIFIED
Unverified assumptions
None beyond the bounded literature-search scope recorded above. In particular, the zero-hit searches do not establish exhaustive literature coverage or first-publication priority.