RESEARCH / Focused target
Mathar's recurrence for the zero-quantum transition pairs A108958
RELEASED FOUNDATIONS / PROPOSED CONNECTION
Research connections
All source anchors (1)
- D5/S3/Combinatorics/ZeroQuantumPairsRecurrence.resultAbsent from this graph
Problem
The question
OEIS A108958 counts the unordered pairs of distinct binary words of length
n with the same number of 1's, a(n) = Σ_{k=0}^{n} C(C(n,k), 2); for n
spins 1/2 these are the nontrivial zero-quantum transitions. Its formula
field records:
Conjecture: n*(n-2)a(n) +2(-3n^2+7n-3)a(n-1) +4(n-1)(2n-3) *a(n-2)=0. - R. J. Mathar, Apr 04 2012
Issue #10598 fixes the reading: a is defined by the entry's first formula
line (also at n = 0, value 0), and the recurrence is asserted for every
n ≥ 2.
Motivation
Our foothold
The entry still marks the recurrence as a conjecture (revision 77,
2025-11-05). D5/S3/Combinatorics/ZeroQuantumPairsRecurrence.result proves
it for every n ≥ 2.
Gap
Missing bridges
Issue #10598 preregisters the proof route and the literature check. The entry
gives the closed form binomial(2n−1, n−1) − 2^(n−1) (Jovovic, 2005) but no
proof of the recurrence; the repository has no declaration about A108958.
not-found-in-searched-scope.
Route
Proposed approach
2 a(n) = Σ_k C(n,k)^2 − Σ_k C(n,k) = C(2n, n) − 2^n.u(n) = C(2n, n)satisfiesn u(n) = 2(2n − 1) u(n − 1), which makes the three-term recurrence foruan identity inu(n − 1).w(n) = 2^nsatisfies the recurrence identically, and the recurrence is linear, soa = (u − w)/2satisfies it.
Falsifier
What would falsify this route
The proof would fail if the closed form of step 1 or the identities of steps
2 and 3 failed for some n ≥ 2.
Evidence
Evidence to collect
Exact integer computation: the recurrence holds for n = 2, …, 299 and
2 a(n) = C(2n, n) − 2^n for n = 0, …, 199 (issue #10598).
The canonical source is
D5/S3/Combinatorics/ZeroQuantumPairsRecurrence.lean.
Its public declarations are a, claim, and result. The frozen module
state has statement identity
sha256:927b7ebb2138f5fbeb71a382fe8b6aa929e43e643e921f62891077b6f983bc13.
The result declaration has statement identity
sha256:a40591f2537a002a1a0b9eec820b55ae6b03587e44c472b212532221be2ca8ec.
The Freeze event is
sha256:536825db74874f9d1e59f65a453748cddc2d8d8441b75ef0a2ca324a6786268a.
It has no project-level frozen prerequisite. The proof uses only the standard
axioms propext, Classical.choice and Quot.sound; no sorry,
native_decide, or new axiom.
Triage
Scope assessment
Tier 1 external named conjecture (OEIS formula field), preregistered in issue
#10598 before the probe. theorem; resolution proved. The public theorem
has proof_shape: bind-only: every atomic fact is an instance of a pinned
Mathlib lemma (the Vandermonde sum of squares, the binomial sum and the central
binomial recurrence), combined by sum distribution and linear arithmetic. The
settlement of the named conjecture is the new content, so the admission basis
is open-problem-resolution; utility none.
ASSUMED-UNVERIFIED
Unverified assumptions
The bounded literature check does not establish exhaustive worldwide novelty, priority, or the absence of an independent proof.